5/12: NY May Bid Farewell to 36% of Young Residents

May 12, 2011 by  
Filed under Featured, Money, Money Vault, State of the Economy

A sizeable proportion of New Yorkers, including more than one-third of those under age 30, may soon be sending out change of address notifications, but those new homes will not be in New York State.  According to this NY1/YNN-Marist Poll, 26% of adults in New York State plan to move someplace else in the next five years while 67% say they will stay.  Just 6% are unsure.  Similar proportions of registered voters statewide share this view.

key exchange

©istockphoto.com/LordRunar

Click Here for Complete May 12, 2011 NYS NY1/YNN-Marist Poll Release and Tables

The picture is even bleaker when looking at the state’s youngest residents.  36% of New Yorkers under 30 years old report they will pack their bags and move to another state.  60%, however, say they will remain in the Empire State, and 3% are unsure.

“New Yorkers are feeling the financial squeeze on the home front.  Right now, many young people do not see their future in New York State,” says Dr. Lee M. Miringoff, Director of The Marist College Institute for Public Opinion.  “Unchecked, this threatens to drain the state of the next generation.”

Older New Yorkers are less likely to move out of New York State in the next five years.  26% of those 30 to 44, 29% of residents 45 to 59, and 16% of those 60 and older think they will switch their state of residence.

Regionally, about one-third — 33% — of those in the suburbs of New York City, 26% of those upstate, and 24% of New York City residents report they will make their exit.

As to the reasons New Yorkers are planning their exit strategies:

  • Of residents who expect to leave New York, more than six in ten — 62% — cite economic reasons like jobs, the cost of living, or taxes.  38%, however, report non-economic reasons such as the proximity to family, overcrowding, quality of life, schools, or retirement as the catalyst.

Table: Plan to Move Out of New York State?

Table: Reason Behind Plans to Move Out of State

Cost of Living: Few View NYS as Affordable

More than three in four adults statewide — 77% — perceive New York to be an expensive place to live for the average family.  Included here are a majority — 55% — who say the overall cost of living is not very affordable and 22% who report it is not affordable at all.  However, 22% say it is affordable while only 1% thinks it is very affordable.  Similar proportions of registered voters in New York State share these views.

Adults in the suburbs of New York City — 87% — and in the city — 80% — are more likely to describe the cost of living in the state as not affordable compared with those upstate — 65%.

Other Key Findings Include:

  • Nearly seven in ten registered voters statewide — 69% — want property taxes to be capped so that they do not rise more than two percent annually.  26% do not, however, for fear that such a cap will cause cuts to local services or raise other taxes.  Five percent are unsure.  There has been relatively no change on this question since NY1/YNN-Marist last reported it in January.
  • More than three in four employed adults in New York State — 76% — say it would be either very difficult or difficult to find a similar job about the same distance from their home if they lost their current position.  Included here are 46% who report it would be very difficult and 30% who say it would be difficult.  19%, though, don’t think it would be very difficult while 5% believe it would not be difficult at all.
  • When it comes to their overall personal family finances, more New York State voters think they will see a change in their family’s financial picture in the upcoming year.  Currently, 47% believe their financial situation will stay about the same while a majority — 54% — thought that way in February.  More than three in ten — 31% — expect their money matters to get better while 22% think they will get worse.  In February, 27% believed an improvement was on the way while 19% expected their finances to diminish.

Table: Cost of Living in NYS

Table: Property Tax Cap

Table: Alternative Employment Near Home

Table: Family Finances in the Coming Year

Table: Family Finances in the Coming Year Over Time

Trend graph: Views of family finances in the coming year

Click on the graph to enlarge the image.

Slight Increase in Voters Who Think NYS Economy is Getting Worse

Although 47% of registered voters statewide believe New York’s economy is about the same as it has been, there has been a slight bump in the proportion who thinks the economy is declining.  37% of registered voters currently report the state’s economy is getting worse compared with 16% who say it is getting better.

When NY1/YNN-Marist last reported this question in early February, half of voters — 50% — said the economy was about the same as it had been previously, 31% thought it was getting worse, and 19% believed it was improving.

“As the state of the economy fails to recover, New Yorkers see this not as a sluggish rebound but as a sluggish economy,” says Dr. Lee M. Miringoff, Director of The Marist College Institute for Public Opinion.

Although there has been little change among Republicans on this question, more non-enrolled voters and Democrats view the economy as deteriorating.  Nearly half of non-enrolled voters — 48% — believe this to currently be the case while about one-third — 33% — thought this way in February.  Among Democrats, 34% have this perception now compared with 26% who said the state’s economy was declining a few months ago.

Table: New York State Economy

Table: New York State Economy Over Time

Trend graph: Impression of New York State economy

Click on the graph to enlarge the image.

 

Economic Glass Half Full or Half Empty: Majority Predict More Bad News

Pessimism about the future of the statewide economy has grown.  A majority of registered voters in New York — 53% — say, when thinking about the economy, the worst is yet to come.  44% are more upbeat and report the worst is behind us, and just 4% are unsure.

When NY1/YNN-Marist last reported this question in early February, voters divided.  At that time, nearly half — 49% — believed the worst was over while 47% thought the worst was ahead.  Four percent were unsure.

While there has been little change among Republicans, there has been a shift among non-enrolled and Democratic voters.  Currently, a majority of non-enrolled voters — 55% — say the worst is yet to come while 42% think the worst is over.  Opinions among non-enrolled voters have flipped since February when a majority — 52% — believed the worst was over while 45% thought the worst was yet to come.

Democrats now divide.  46% of these voters expect more economic challenges in the future while 48% say they are in the past.  A few months ago, 40% said more bad news was ahead while a majority — 56% — predicted the worst was over.  Among Republicans, 60% think the worst is yet to come compared with 37% who report the worst is over.  A few months ago, those proportions stood at 57% and 39%, respectively.

While there has been little change in the proportion of voters in New York City’s suburbs — 48% — who think the worst of the economy’s problems are ahead, more voters upstate — 57% — and those in New York City — 50% — have this view.  In early February, the proportions in each of these regions stood at 49%, 48%, and 45%, respectively.

Table: NYS Economy – Will it Get Worse?

NY1/YNN-Marist Poll Methodology

 

Comments

25 Responses to “5/12: NY May Bid Farewell to 36% of Young Residents”

  1. Is New York Bringing You Down? - NYTimes.com on May 13th, 2011 4:43 pm

    [...] Yorkers’ love-hate relationship with the city is a perennial theme, but according to a statewide poll by NY1/YNN — Marist College released on Thursday, there is a quantifiable disdain for living [...]

  2. Sleeping Dog on May 13th, 2011 5:16 pm

    One problem with these polls or the reporting on these polls, is that no context is given. A reader has no idea whether this is a change from the past, nor if that change could be considered a positive or negative for the state. Significantly more interesting and valuable are reports that actually detail the numbers of individuals who have moved and why.

  3. John Abrams. on May 13th, 2011 7:10 pm

    This shouldn’t be a suprize. The city is like a third world country .

  4. Young New Yorkers Planning to Flee | The Lonely Conservative on May 13th, 2011 9:13 pm

    [...] whopping 36% of young New Yorkers plan to flee the state, according to a new poll. If you live in a low tax red state, you better hope they don’t move there, or they’ll [...]

  5. Bruce on May 14th, 2011 12:19 am

    Welcome to reality young New Yorkers….

    Just leave your “progressive” politics in NY when you migrate. If are a true believer we don’t need you in in a productive society. Let’s be straight up here: “Social Justice” swallowed whole, force fed in the university; will quickly be spit up when the bills come due.

    Welcome to personal responsibility, freedom and the betterment of your future family. You are an adult now. Leave your childish ways in NY.

  6. The Economic Power of the Marcellus in NY | Energy In Depth – Northeast Marcellus Initiative on May 14th, 2011 6:12 am

    [...]  A recently released by Marist Poll suggests why New Yorkers ought to be interested in what Holko had to [...]

  7. The consequence of raising taxes on May 14th, 2011 7:22 am

    [...] because they can not cope with higher taxes along with the plain cost of surviving in that city. New York May Bid Farewell to 36% of Young Residents | Home of the Marist Poll: Pebbles and Pundits Of course, the experts tell us that people will not flee higher taxes. Studies: Rich Don't Flee [...]

  8. Stephen Macklin on May 14th, 2011 7:47 am

    I’m sure there’s a way the NRLB can stop them.

  9. John on May 14th, 2011 2:17 pm

    Good. I left 6 years ago and life has never been better.

    But if you do: LEAVE YOUR SOCIALIST VOTING HABITS BACK IN THE STATE YOU HELPED DESTROY.

    Do not come to America and vote for liberals, communists and community organizers. They made the state you are fleeing uninhabitable, do not bring them with you or we will ask yoiu to leave. That bs is not welcome here.

    Here, we value human freedom. Here, we do not believe that you have a right to enslave your neighbor and steal the fruit of his labor, not even with “the best of intentions.”

  10. New poll finds young NY’ers ready to move out | Doobybrain.com on May 14th, 2011 4:17 pm

    [...] A new Marist Poll has found that a good portion of young New York residents plan to move out of the state in 5 years or less. Add me to that figure please. A sizeable proportion of New Yorkers, including more than one-third of those under age 30, may soon be sending out change of address notifications, but those new homes will not be in New York State. According to this NY1/YNN-Marist Poll, 26% of adults in New York State plan to move someplace else in the next five years while 67% say they will stay. Just 6% are unsure. Similar proportions of registered voters statewide share this view. [...]

  11. Anne on May 14th, 2011 4:19 pm

    “Schools” are listed as a “non-economic” reason, but in fact, the school decision is a highly economically-motivated one. Private schools can cost upwards of $25K / year per child In NYC. Tutors and “cram schools” to get kids up to the standards of private school admissions cost a lot of money too. Living in a better neighborhood in Manhattan does *not* guarantee you access to your neighborhood school, especially at the middle- and high school levels. So for many, private school is the only option, especially given the vagaries of NYC’s so-called “school choice” plans, which in actuality are, “We will tell you where you are going to school.” So yes, money is a huge factor in school decisions.

  12. Moonlight Swim-14 May 11 | adeliemanchot on May 15th, 2011 12:56 am

    [...] they say they are they better leave their leftist voting habits at the border on the way out…NY May Bid Farewell to 36% of Young Residents “New Yorkers are feeling the financial squeeze on the home front.  Right now, many young people [...]

  13. Brace Yourself for A Hipster Invasion « sitting on the edge of the sandbox, biting my tongue on May 15th, 2011 12:45 pm

    [...] Instapundit: young New Yorkers are pessimistic about the future and threatening to leave the state.  Ah!  But New Yorkers are apparently already leaving in droves — for San Francisco.  [...]

  14. Listening to Each Other | The Retirement Bubble on May 23rd, 2011 6:25 pm

    [...] and lack of jobs are the primary reasons people are moving. If you like, you can read the Marist press release or you can download a copy of their [...]

  15. One in Four N.Y. Adults Planning to Leave State - City-Data Forum on May 24th, 2011 11:12 am

    [...] One in Four N.Y. Adults Planning to Leave State There is an interesting article in this week's CNY Business Journal about people planning on moving out of New York. The article is based on this survey: New York May Bid Farewell to 36% of Young Residents | Home of the Marist Poll: Pebbles and Pundits [...]

  16. Money Woes Make Young New Yorkers Want to Flee the City, Poll Finds ‹ Kareem Johnson | Multimedia Journalist – Portfolio Site on May 26th, 2011 10:32 pm

    [...] Yorkers polled under the age of 30 said they’re seriously considering moving out of state, according to numbers in a new NY1/YNN-Marist College poll released [...]

  17. Rynstone on May 30th, 2011 6:40 pm

    We continue to educate out of state students at in-state student rates after their freshman year at our SUNY schools.
    We are subsidizing all SUNY students educations and many of them will have to leave the state to find gainful employment which means they will not be contributing to the system that subsidized the cost of their education.

    Many SUNY administrative salaries are too high for our state’s economics woes.

    The SUNY schools and public schools have been promised wages and benefits that we can no longer afford.
    Our politicians have promised more than we can afford. For years they have been writing checks that we the residents of NY can not cover.

  18. Abhishek on June 2nd, 2011 10:17 am

    There will be a similar trend in London in the coming years.. followed by all major cities around the world. With the economies dwindling and prices soaring through the roof, not much can be done to hold the young population who dont seem to feel satisfied when their demands are not met. There is only an evergrowing frustration in the hearts of the youth and this is all justified! long live America

  19. Bill Suter on June 15th, 2011 4:01 pm

    I found it interesting that younger New Yorkers, those under 30, were planning to move out of state in larger number then older New Yorkers, in the next 5 years; during the same time frame when baby boomers will start leaving the work force. I believe that this is the beginning of a trend from younger persons that have not experience the up and down cycles of our Economy. I love this poll so much that I’m going to bookmark it for you.

  20. 1/3 of Younger New Yorkers plan on leaving the state. - FIX NYC on June 15th, 2011 7:15 pm

    [...] Read the full NY1/YNN Marist Poll [...]

  21. vpn service on November 27th, 2011 2:07 am

    There is an interesting article in this week’s CNY Business Journal about people planning on moving out of New York. The article is based on this survey:

  22. Middle class? What’s that? | CENTS & THE CITY on December 4th, 2011 2:30 am

    [...] states, but when you see some of the other factors mentioned in this article, it’s no wonder 24% of New York City residents plan to make their exodus out of the most expensive city in the country (and 32nd in the world). According to “The 12 [...]

  23. shepard on February 21st, 2012 8:56 am

    For those of you who cite NYC, think again. There is a HUGE upstate New York. Secondly, if the same questions were asked of residents in other states, what’s to say the results wouldn’t be similar. The economy woes are global.

  24. Allan Levine on September 9th, 2012 6:43 pm

    No, it’s not the same in other states and no it wasn’t always like this. Young people used to move to NY state for opportunity. Basically, the blue Liberal big government states are all failing. Leaner Red states are generally doing better. Not NY nor any of the other Blue states were on Boeing’s short list of where to build it’s next US factory.
    Companies are fleeing California daily. New York’s led or been at or near the top of this statistic for a while.

  25. Smith on July 31st, 2013 3:14 pm

    This trend has been ongoing since at least the ’90s. There are simply no jobs in upstate ny. Manufacturing is dead, and even people with skills are having a hard time surviving. Go to small towns in the southern tier and it’s so bad you have people competing for part time fast food gigs. It’s just an extension of appalacia at this point. I left soon after graduating high school and don’t regret it. Came back briefly and it was the biggest mistake I made. Being from upstate, the situation is albany is always hopeless, and it seems nothing can get done. The only way to possibly recover is to split the state in two, but that will never happen. Get your act together NYS, you aren’t going down the drain, your in the sewer!

Feel free to leave a comment...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!