8/14: Voters Divide on Obama’s Handling of Health Care

August 14, 2009 by  
Filed under Featured, Health Care, Health Care Archive, Politics

As the debate over health care reform rages on in Congress and in the public realm, President Barack Obama needs to do more to convince the American electorate that health care reform is the right course of action.  45% of registered U.S. voters say they disapprove of how the president is handling health care while 43% approve.



Not surprisingly, opinion is fractured along party lines with 74% of Democrats approving of how the president is dealing with the issue and 76% of Republicans disapproving of President Obama’s methods.  Independents align with the GOP on this matter.  A majority of Independents — 52% — are unhappy with how Mr. Obama is addressing the health care situation in the United States.  There is also a large racial split.  Overwhelmingly, African American voters approve of how the president is dealing with health care.  87% report President Obama is handling the situation appropriately while just 6% think he is not.  White voters, on the other hand, tip the scales in the opposite direction.  52% of whites disapprove while 38% approve.  Latino members of the electorate fall in the middle with 44% saying they agree with the president’s actions, and 32% reporting they do not.

Table: Handling of Health Care

Majority of Americans: Major Changes Needed, But Health Care Situation Will Not Improve

Although 65% of U.S. residents, including 67% of registered voters nationwide, think the country’s health care system needs major change, many are not optimistic about the impact of health care reform.

If Congress passes health care legislation, just 39% of Americans say health care in this country will get better.  55%, on the other hand, report that it will get worse or stay the same.  Registered voters closely reflect the views of the overall population.

Once again, party affiliation comes into play. 65% of Democrats believe reform will improve the status of the nation’s health care while almost the identical proportion of Republicans — 63% — say it will worsen it.   Looking at Independents, a plurality — 44% — believe reform will be a detriment to the system while 30% say it will be an improvement.

Older Americans are much more pessimistic about the future of the nation’s health care situation than are younger U.S. residents.  Although similar proportions within both age groups believe health care will improve, more residents age 45 and older — 43% — believe it will get worse compared with 32% of their younger counterparts.

How will health care reform affect Americans personally?  Just 28% of U.S. residents think health care for themselves and their families will get better while 67% think it will get worse or remain the same.  This includes nearly one-third of Americans — 32% — who believe it will get worse.  Voters here, too, are in line with the overall population.

Democrats are more optimistic than are Republicans on this question.  42% believe their personal health care situation will improve while 40% think it will stay the same.  Just 13% of Democrats say it will get worse.  Republicans are Democrats’ polar opposites here.  54% of Republicans say their health care will get worse, 31% report it will stay the same, and only 10% think it will get better.

Once again, older Americans are less optimistic than are younger residents.  36% of those 45 and older believe their personal health care circumstances will get worse while 27% of younger residents agree.

Table: Amount of Health Care Reform Needed
Table: Impact of Reform on National Health Care
Table: Impact of Reform on Personal Health Care

Nearly a Quarter to Blame Democrats in Congress if Health Care Doesn’t Meet Expectations

Who do Americans say is most responsible if health care legislation doesn’t live up to their expectations? 24% of residents say it’s the Democrats’ fault, 20% report the pharmaceutical companies are to blame, 15% point the finger at President Obama, 14% would fault the Republicans, and 12% blame doctors and hospitals.

Republicans are playing party politics on this question more than are the Democrats. 40% of Republicans say they would hold the Democrats responsible if health care legislation does not meet their expectations. On the other side of the aisle, Democrats are less likely to point the finger at Republicans.  25% of Democrats say they would hold members of the GOP accountable. More than a quarter of Independents — 26% — believe Democrats would be responsible.  This proportion is followed closely by pharmaceutical companies.

Table: Responsibility for Failing to Meet Expectations

Marist Poll Methodology

Related Stories:

Complete August 14, 2009 USA Release & Tables


10 Responses to “8/14: Voters Divide on Obama’s Handling of Health Care”

  1. Hot Air » Blog Archive » Poll: Give back the Porkulus money on August 14th, 2009 12:55 pm

    [...] Marist also polls registered voters on their approval of Obama’s performance on health care, and the numbers look bad.  Independents once again provide the momentum away from a wounded administration: As the debate over health care reform rages on in Congress and in the public realm, President Barack Obama needs to do more to convince the American electorate that health care reform is the right course of action.  45% of registered U.S. voters say they disapprove of how the president is handling health care while 43% approve. [...]

  2. ilovebenefits on August 14th, 2009 1:15 pm

    There has been a great deal of talk in the media — print, radio, tv — just about everywhere about the behavior and tactics being employed by various organizations. There have been comments about well behaved and polite citizenry attending meetings to voice their opinions. There have been stories of those who haven’t conducted themselves well. I suspect these stories will go on throughout the month of August and perhaps beyond. For one, I hope they do go on well beyond.
    I think both sides have taken essentially the same tactics. Labeling each other with invectives, giving their supporters a ‘playbook’, and attempting to use the media to their advantage. All of this is okay. It is okay because in America we have the right to freedom of speech, assembly and freedom of the press. These are rights that thousands have given their lives to protect. The debate on health care which consumes nearly a fifth of the national economy and involves everyone is something that we should openly debate and understand the intended and unintended consequences of before we change an entire system.
    It is important to provide better access, bend the cost curve so that health care is affordable (and not just through shifting costs by taxing) as well as sustainable, and improving the quality of the care delivered.
    We are a country that leads the world in health care innovation. We have to zealously protect that aspect. No other country in the world is positioned to take our place if we take our eye off this important work.
    But above all democracy demands that citizens get involved and voice their opinions. To follow the health care debate and other important facts about he health care system visit http://www.ilovebenefits.wordpress.com

  3. Gary Muyskens on August 14th, 2009 10:24 pm

    ok…….here is the jist of it
    IF the conservatives have managed to convince the majority of Americans that THEY have a better grasp of health care then I say(although I am frightened of their dubious “reforms”)let them have it!….call their bluff, why not?
    It would serve to end this nonsense once and for all, if it works…then hey, great….if it doesn’t, then I would expect the call for reform to be re-energized and the desire to actually be spooked by fear tactics to finally fall on deaf ears, and then MAYBE we may actually get reform passed

  4. Polls Show Tough Fight For Health Overhaul | Swine Flu Daily Update on August 15th, 2009 5:46 am

    [...] Marist Poll is out with numbers this morning that show President Obama has a lot of work left to do if he hopes to remake the country’s [...]

  5. Photomaniacal » Blog Archive » Taking the poison out of healthcare | Bilal Baloch on August 27th, 2009 5:57 pm

    [...] are equally to blame for the hazy summer confusion that has set in. The Marist Poll found that the debate has led 67% of registered voters into pessimism about the details of [...]

  6. Dispatches from the bubble on September 4th, 2009 11:34 am

    [...] have noticed the extent to which he’s still buoyed by firm support from that base: As Marist put it last month, "Overwhelmingly, African American voters approve of how the president is [...]

  7. Hispanics A Tough Sell On Health Care Reform « Sherria Cotton on June 11th, 2010 12:32 pm

    [...] are more pessimistic about the current legislation than most, according to the results of a Marist poll of nearly 1,000 people released Aug. 14. When asked what impact passage of health care reform would [...]

  8. Motivated Seller on August 27th, 2010 4:05 pm

    The health care debate is a tricky one. Some people call it Socialism at its best.

  9. Gordon on October 5th, 2010 7:48 am

    I would agree with the Socialism at its best statement. I would like to see health care being more affordable for more of our people. It is extremely important to feel secure in the time you need it the most. This reform would help many more get health care coverage and I am all for it. Naturally, the benefits and drawbacks need to be debated and reanalyzed so that we end up with best health care system possible.

  10. xenki on January 4th, 2011 11:12 am

    really interesting debate when we talk for health

Feel free to leave a comment...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!