7/2: Don’t Know Much About History?
July 2, 2010 by Marist Poll
Filed under Celebrations, Celebrations Polls, Featured, Living
There’s good news for American education. About three-quarters of residents — 74% — know the U.S. declared its independence from Great Britain in 1776. The bad news for the academic system — 26% do not. This 26% includes one-fifth who are unsure and 6% who thought the U.S. separated from another nation. That begs the question, “From where do the latter think the U.S. achieved its independence?” Among the countries mentioned are France, China, Japan, Mexico, and Spain.
©istockphoto.com/Kaupang
Table: Country from Which U.S. Declared Independence
Check out The Marist Poll’s mention on Countdown with Keith Olbermann
· 
Print This Post
·
Or it could be that as much as 26% of respondents found the survey question so absurd that they intentionally gave incorrect answers.
Or it could be that 26% of respondents misheard the question or had a technical error.
Or it could be that 26% of respondents have a non-Euro-centric view of history. For instance, how does a Native American interpret the concept of US independence? Their people were hear first, and their lands were taken away from them. They might interpret the question very differently, and may even find the suggestion of US ‘independence’ offensive.
Consider also that many parts of the US were formerly colonies of other nations, in particular, the French and Spanish, and rather than ‘winning their independence’ they were purchased or won in other wars (see for instance: The Louisiana Territory, Texas, Alaska).
The author of this entry should not be too prideful about his or her own education. The author has misunderstood and misused the phrase “begs the question.” The phrase means to base an answer on an assumption that itself is unproven. It does not mean “invites the obvious question.” So the ironic subtitle could have been “Don’t know much about the English Language.”
.. scary ..
Careful yourself there, Mr. Hager! While you are quite right that “begs the question” derives from “petitio principii” and originally had the meaning you set forth, language is a funny thing. Meanings change through usage. This alternative use is rather widespread. Moreover, you yourself understood the concept the author sought to convey. Insofar as language is a communicative act, mission accomplished. While this use of “begs the question” is probably still ill-advised in formal writing, I’d be cautious about going so far as saying the author “misused” the phrase.
@grand: …or how many of the respondents were educated in the US?
Ok… two points.
1) The post acts like a respondents saying they are “unsure” is the same as “doesn’t know”, but looking at the crosstabs, there is a huge gender gap on the unsure response. This makes it likely that “unsure” is mostly picking up a difference in willingness to attempt an answer, not a true difference in knowledge.
2) How is this any news for the US educational system? Read your own methodology. Marist made no attempt to exclude respondents based on whether they had been educated in the US or not.
[...] fourth of July is Independence Day in the US. 1,004 US residents were asked who independence was declared from. The results? A little concerning, shall we say. [...]
Great Britain is an island, not a country. We gained indepence from the United Kingdom.
grand @ 1:
Nice apologetics. You don’t really believe that, do you? You know as well as I do that you’re just trying to pretend that a full quarter of America’s population are g*****n idiots.
John Hager @ 2:
Yes, you’re technically correct. He should have said “raises the question”. But the fact is that “begs” has been used and understood that way, and not in the technical sense, for an extremely long time. You knew what he meant and so did everyone else, so get over yourself. Not to mention the fact “begs the question” is itself a mistranslation of the French which makes essentially no sense in English. Only idiotic stubbornness and pretentious s**** like you have kept an utterly unintuitive piece of language fluffery alive.
That should be “… population *aren’t* …”.
The Marist Poll asked: “On July 4th we celebrate Independence Day. From which country did the United States win its independence?”
The question seems to pretty much exclude the Louisiana Purchase (1803), Texas (1845), and Alaska (1867), none of which could conceivably be thought of in the context of “win its independence.”
And given that Native Americans account for less than 1% of the population (http://www.census.gov/population/www/socdemo/race/censr-28.pdf), I would suspect any responses they provided didn’t skew the results all that much.
In other news, 26% of people polled support the Tea Party.
grand (1st comment) is a total moron who has obviously been overschooled in sensitivity training and failed to learn some basic facts. ‘Euro-centric view of history’ – what on earth are you talking about? It was England that the 13 colonies of the United States gained independence from. This is not subject to some type of post modern interpretation. It is a fact and if you think they accientally polled 26% indians, you are mental. What is another possible answer?
Young people don’t care about who we won our independence from 220 some years ago. If they need to know they can just google it. And yet, I bet my neighbor kids (3 and 2nd graders) can answer that question without hesitation if it is asked in a manner in which they understand what’s being asked. I would guess most midwestern kids can answer this. Why is that?
@Beefeater:
The “United Kingdom” didn’t come into being until later, when Ireland was added. In 1776 the political entity of England, Scotland, and Wales was known as the Kingdom of Great Britain.
[...] Day Weekend Posted on July 2, 2010 by dakinikat A Marist poll found that about 26% don’t know who from who the U.S. declared independence in 1776. The bad [...]
I’m not sure they actually teach this lesson in school. It’s simply assumed that everyone knows it. I of course know it, but I don’t recall ever having been taught it in school. I simply picked it up by osmosis from our culture, growing up.
@A: You mean, Northern Ireland.
Correction, my mistake. The whole Ireland was part of the UK for a time.
I would like to see this same poll run in the UK, or at least in England. Might be interesting.
[...] and, when the sun goes down, plenty of fireworks. I love the fellowship. I’m dismayed at the ignorance of some of my fellow Americans, of course. But I think the holiday can serve an educational purpose without dampening the [...]
How did all this discussion miss such an obvious error as the mis-use of the word “hear” in the 3rd sentence of the 3rd paragraph?
“Their people were hear first, their lands taken from them…..”
The correct useage is “here”.
I, for one don’t think this was a typo given all the other mis-information posited by the writer. I don’t think the writer knows the between the two spellings. Another case of being taught ‘sensitivity’ over being taught facts. It is a safe bet the writer is under 30.
There are obviously a large number of History teachers commenting on the results of this poll because I can not believe so many people are willing to make excuses for these appalling results.
#1: Before you write any more, learn the difference between ‘here’ and ‘hear’.
Carol:
“In other news, 26% of people polled support the Tea Party.”
Actually, I bet that about 99% of the 26% are Obama voters. Tea Party supporters (and conservatives in general) generally have some familiarity with the Declaration of Independence.
Previous poster: “In other news, 26% of people polled support the Tea Party.”
As in “Boston Tea Party”? A rather ironic (if not convoluted) way to try to portray the Tea Partiers as being made up exclusively of ignoramuses.
First, the Louisiana Purchase has nothing to do with our declaring independence. Nor does anything else that came later. Grand, you’re an idiot if you actually believe some of those things you wrote. Thee is no such thing as a Native American, they just got here before us and they were warring among themselves for a long time before we came along. Last, I know quite a few immigrants and they probably know our history better than the average native born American. They had to take a citizenship test.
@Confluence, @Beefeater:
The “United Kingdom” didn’t come into being until later, when Ireland was added. In 1776 the political entity of England, Scotland, and Wales was known as the Kingdom of Great Britain.
Actually, it was called “The United Kingdom of Great Britain”. When Ireland was added in 1800, it became “The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland”.
This survey result might be because 26% of the respondents were illegal aliens, who could barely speak English. They thought they were ordering take-out food when they were taking this survey.
Carol
Let’s take 10 Tea Party members and 10 average Obama voters and ask the question. I will bet 10 grand to your life savings of 50 bucks that no fewer than 9 tea party members know the answer and 5 or less average Obama voters know it. Let’s roll.
@Beefeater: sorry to disagree; but we did in fact gain our independence from Great Britain (created when James the VII of Scotland also became James I of England ca 1701). The “United Kingdom” doesn’t come into existence until passage of the Act of Union in the Year of Our Lord 1800.
They should have followed up with the 26% with the question: Whom did you vote for in the 2008 Presidential contest? I’m guessing 100% would say Obama.
I’m not sure which worries me more: the results of this poll or the bone-headed attempts by some comments here to rationalize it. Frank Zappa was right: the most abundant element in the universe is not hydrogen but stupidity.
@grand . . . Robert’s already said most of what I had to say – and very well, too – so I’ll just fire off two things:
1. The I-D-10-T error is the only kind of “technical error” I know that would preclude answering a straightforward question which doesn’t have more than one answer.
2. The Louisiana Purchase, the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo and such and such were made AFTER the US won its independence. Not before. You’re confusing the creation of a whole new country for the addition of states to a particular country, and worse yet making excuses for people to do so.
Your reasoning is off-the-charts, amazingly, without a doubt pathetic.
Let me guess, you were educated in a public school with far-left faculty. Am I right?
[...] celebrating, and, by extension, the country they live in? As July 4 approaches this Sunday, a Marist poll shows that 26 percent of Americans, including 40 percent of 18- to 29-year-olds, don’t know [...]
Carol, you are purposefully and intentionally misinformed about the Tea Party from the pro-liberal media (and, most likely, your own political ideology).
The Tea Party members give out booklets of the Constitution to the crowds to read and also advocate the reading of the Federalist Papers as primary sources.
Tea Party members are better informed than most Americans regarding our country’s founding as they are proponents of returning to our Constitutionally limited federal government.
And 113% of the 26% was registered by ACORN to vote for Obama.
“In other news, 26% of people polled support the Tea Party.”
And in still more news, 45% of people polled support Barry Obama. There is a theory, though, that many of these people found the question so absurd that they intentionally gave an incorrect answer. Otherwise, there’s really no explanation for responses so incongruous with reality.
Let the libs say what they want about all the stupid yokels. I guarantee the yokels at least know of our won independence from the English. The liberal base, however? You know, the urban folk? Walk down the streets of any major inner city in America and ask them who we declared and won independence from. If you don’t get insulted, threatened, robbed, stabbed or handed a rumpled Obama ’08 bumper sticker, they probably wouldn’t know they answer. 26% is optimistic. But yes, they still get to vote. And yes, we know who they will vote for every single time.
Polls need to be taken with a big grain of salt. Unless you know the demographics, the language used, etc. we should never accept poll answers as some kind of Cassandra utterance. That said, when I was substitute-teaching for k-8, i found that the one subject that i could drop from the curriculum was History. Why? Because it was not a tested subject in the “no child left behind”-mandated tests. If i were running out of time, then history was the first casualty.
I’m finding most of the comments very disgusting, either saying it really doesn’t matter or somehow this was a trick question. Let’s be REALLY clear: This is NOT a trick question, even the dumbest American with the lowest IQ should be able to answer it and it is a VERY big deal. People who are this ignorant cannot remain free. Stupidity and freedom don’t mix. Do you think these lazy, ignorant people know what their constitutional rights are? Do you think they have any idea what their government can or can not do to them? Liberals who run the public schools have been dumbing down our children for decades. Why? Stupid people are easily led by government tyrants and government is the liberals’ god.
democratic voters have to come from somwhere. that 26% is their base. if we educated enough people, there would be no need for the dem party. come on. let them have something.
My six year old daughter asked, “do these people vote, Mommy?”
robert lynch: why would indians care about our indepedence. i think they are more concerend with their independence from great brit in 1947 (or 1950 depending on how you slice it). or did you mean “native americans”? i think you need some sensitivity training……/sarc
Justyn,
Are you kidding me? Please tell me you’re joking. My daughter has covered basic American history a couple of times now and she’s just in 5th grade. They covered it at least in 4th and 5th grade. Maybe even 3rd (I don’t remember).
@Carol
I’d bet my savings account that 95% plus of Tea Party members know who we declared independence from. I also bet that a majority of them would know basic economic principles. I’d also bet that the Tea Party would poll higher on the differences between Austrian and Keynesian economics than the general public.
‘The phrase [begs the question] means to base an answer on an assumption that itself is unproven.”
Don’t be overly prideful of your own education, otherwise you make a fool of yourself by correcting others with errors of your own.
Begging the question means assuming as a premise the conclusion of your argument.
Yes, between the two errors by Marist Poll:
1. England
2. Begs the Question
Marist Poll certainly gets an F. Or maybe King George III was King of Great Britain?
LOL
26%? I didn’t know Pelosi had that many relatives.
Justyn, if you didn’t learn this in school, then your school might be an example of what is wrong with America’s education system. I don’t consider any of the schools I went to to be particularly great, but I definitely learned that in elementary, middle and high school history. But you raise a point that even if a person didn’t learn it in school, you don’t have to pay THAT much attention to culture to know the answer.
@1 Are you kidding?
@grand… Having a “non-Eurocentric view” is an irrelevant rationalization for people in this country to not know who the 13 American colonies revolted against. In fact, it doesn’t require a “Eurocentric view” at all since it involved North America. By the way, Native Americans were actively involved during the Revolutionary War – on BOTH sides. And also, it’s HERE, not “hear,’ genius…
Likely the ones who think the colonies separated from either China, France etc. were Democrats.
The scary point for me is if those 26% vote?
grand said: “Or it could be that 26% of respondents have a non-Euro-centric view of history. For instance, how does a Native American interpret the concept of US independence? Their people were hear (sic) first, and their lands were taken away from them. They might interpret the question very differently, and may even find the suggestion of US ‘independence’ offensive.”
Well, let’s look at this. The UNITED STATES were not the Native Americans. People weren’t “hear” first but rather here first.
grand also said: “Consider also that many parts of the US were formerly colonies of other nations, in particular, the French and Spanish, and rather than ‘winning their independence’ they were purchased or won in other wars (see for instance: The Louisiana Territory, Texas, Alaska).”
Well, it is true those places were NOT part of the new UNITED STATES until AFTER the revolution. But they HAVE been part of the UNITED STATES for a very long time. Not many people are alive today when only a few of these were not. So I really think your “arguments” are full of steaming male bovine refuse.
Grand.
You’re argument about the “Eurocentric” view of the world is completely off base. If somebody is living in the modern day united states, they have no excuse to not know the answer to this simple question.
The whole “I’m an indian and I’m offended that the US is an independent country” doesn’t hold water. It’s been a country (one of the worlds most influential) for well over 200 years. Indians in our country have far more exposure to the US government that most other citizens.
It’s not like we have a large aboriginal population living in isolation in distant jungles or anything.
You know as well as I do that most of those who didn’t know were just ignorant ghetto queens who dropped out of 6th grade.
[...] if that’s not enough, check out Marist: There’s good news for American education. About three-quarters of residents — 74% — know the [...]
What I think is funnier than the ignorance of 26% of the respondents is the eagerness of commenters here to explain it away, as if some answer other than “England” showed a heightened nuance rather than pure-D dumbness. You know, what if they got all wrapped up in the concept of the Louisiana Purchase or something, because their grasp of history was so deep, broad, sophisticated, and sensitive? That’s the ticket, ace. Keep #^*&ing that chicken.
[...] if that’s not enough, check out Marist: There’s good news for American education. About three-quarters of residents — 74% — know the [...]
Most of the above answers miss an obvious point: The answer to the question — i.e., the country from which we declared independence — can be found in . . . . (drum roll) . . . . . . the DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE! Even a cursory reading of this one-page document will quickly reveal that it is aimed at the King of Great Britain.
What is really alarming is that these people vote and procreate.
@Phil No, the name “United Kingdom of Great Britain” is sometimes applied retroactively, but the Acts of Union provided that “the two kingdoms of Scotland and England shall, . . . for ever after, be united into one kingdom by the name of Great Britain.”
I realize some people like to flaunt the fact that the know the difference between “England,” “Great Britain,” and “the United Kingdom,” but there’s a time and a place. And the time in question is before 1800.
[...] you think “Hey! It’s Independence Day!” You bask in the knowledge that you are one of the 74% of Americans who know what country our founding fathers declared independence from. So you decide to grab that dog and [...]
Back in the late 1980s roughly only 66% of all Seniors graduating from US High Schools could name the Capital of the United States of America. This 26% is well within that error.
yeah dude. was kidding. kinda got a chuckle from the one about the “eurocentric education”. and i agree with you. on all of what you said. and i dont think i am a liberal. but some days i wonder. but i think it is “liberals” more than the converse, that tend to apply labels like that. and those labels i think separate us, more than they unify us.
I would have answered “England” Would that have been marked “wrong”? And what if someone answered “UK”? Did the answer need to be “Great Britain” to be considered correct?
[...] America Declared its Independence from _______. In Obama, polls on July 3, 2010 at 9:13 pm From which country did the United States win its independence? One in four Americans don’t know that the correct answer is Great Britain, and one in five Americans don’t have any clue at all. This is according to a new poll conducted by Marist Poll. [...]
[...] Overall, 20 percent of the population answered “not sure” to the question, while six percent declared it to be a country other than Great Britain. “Among the countries mentioned are France, China, Japan, Mexico, and Spain,” Marist reports. [...]
Don’t put too much stock in polls like this one. It’s possible that it shows exactly what it claims, but more likely than not there’s another explanation. About five years ago I saw a poll – that was reproduced in a textbook on US government – that said about 25% of college-age Americans could not locate the US on a globe. It wasn’t until a few months later that I looked into the matter in more detail and found that people from other countries had comparable and equally appalling rates. Now you could assume from that study and this one and perhaps South Park’s 9/11-conspiracy conspiracy episode that “one fourth of America is retarded.” Or you could remain skeptical of polls and learn a bit more before jumping to conclusions.
[...] educated are Americans regarding their own history? Here’s the good news- about 74% of people can name the country that America declared independence from in 1776. Here’s [...]
It’s simply amazing that you can’t present any fact of any kind in this country without the Republicans and Democrats turning it into fodder for yet another of their irrelevant little slapfights.
[...] Overall, 20 percent of the population answered “not sure” to the question, while six percent declared it to be a country other than Great Britain. “Among the countries mentioned are France, China, Japan, Mexico, and Spain,” Marist reports. [...]
None of you seem to know anything about Native Americans.
We are neither grossly uneducated, nor nonexistent. Bill R. you sound like some kind of American Zionist— you are one scary white dude. Newsflash: manifest destiny is no longer entitled by the law.
And for the record, there are some reservations that are VERY isolated, where there are older folks who still don’t speak English (often as a matter of Pride in their assorted traditional languages), but even those reservations have schools, and generally they are really thinning out, as people leave them for other places that are not so completely founded upon their marginalization.
Sorry to tell you folks, we walk among you. I know. It’s a real downer.
And to bring up yet another point, can anyone tell me why it’s even important to know this particular fact about the United States, other than the fact that most people do? What is its essential relevance to anything? Who really cares? What could this piece of information possibly do for you, other than get you through the “complete moron” level of a quiz show.
Actually there is some reason for the confusion, at least in the West. Both California and Texas gained their independence from Mexico, and became independent republics before joining the United States, one a territory won and ceded to the US in the Mexican-American War and the other a recent (peaceful) addition to the US whose annexation sparked that conflict. It doesn’t excuse not knowing from which nation the original 13 colonies declared independence, but it would explain the confusion for any who read or heard the question as “from what country did WE win our independence,” as residents of those states would be aware of their own state’s history as much as that of the US itself.
The poll is not perfect but it does speak to some things.
Why did 40% of people age 18-29 not know this?
Why do 33% of women not know this?
Why do people with less income score worse than people with more?
Why do non white people score worse than those that are white?
What can we do as a nation to correct these questions and others?
I do think history matters. If we don’t learn we are doomed to repeat. I wonder how many people would correctly answer the question “who was the united states major ally in the war for independance from great britan?”
Actually studies show that liberals ARE more intelligent than conservatives. So, chances are Obama supporters would win out!
SEE LINK
http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1968042,00.html
I’d like to know what the actual question was and what options were given in what order. It makes ALL the difference! But I still can’t laugh hard enough that the highest fraction of people who gave the wrong or uncertain (also wrong) answer are in the South, by a wide margin. Expect the full results to show up on Fox News any second now–but not the bit about the South.
I can’t believe how ridiculous everyones comments are on the subject. Because no one has really said anything at all, just calling out each others verbal flubs.
Stats are dumb and you guys are all wasting your time
I would be interested in more insight into the demographics of the 26%. There have been no shortage of people here assuming that the 26% are representative of people that disagree with them. (By the way it’s a statistical certainty that even if all of the 26% were eligible to vote most of them did not.) I think it would be instructive, for example, to know the break down by public/private/home school. I would suggest that to the extent the respondents were taught in private schools or home schooled the information does not reflect anything about any level of Government (except that we have the freedom to make bad education decisions for our children). To the extent that the respondents were educated in the American public schools, I would suggest that every single public school in the country has this fact in their curriculum, so if the students didn’t learn or retain that fact it that is a failure of the schools to meet their goals. Failure to meet those goals could result from a lot of things but I can’t think of one possible reason that can’t be classified as “lack of resources.” So I would focus on people that think vouchers help schools, or that buying bombs is more important than hiring teachers, or that there’s no harm in taking time out of the curriculum to teach “creation science” in addition to biology should consider the practical ramifications of their abstract political philosophy.
That’s just pathetic
Thanks to Will Smith and Jeff Goldblum, the U.S. declared its independence from the aliens on July 4th, 1996. What more do you want to know?
Now we are independent from China! No more Chinese war bonds!
Is Northern Ireland considered part of your island of Great Britain Beefeater? Last time I checked the Brits still think so and yet water needs to be crossed to get there from England. If you’re going to be a wise ass do a bit of research.
The authority of the survey
It’s not a matter of liberals like many extremists would suggest. Most of you conservatives were educated in the liberal public schhol system. The truth is that there are morons and plain old fashioned dummies on both ends of the political spectrum. I’ve lived the Appalachian heartland of conservativsim and the liberal cites of the east coast. Dumbness is rampant everywhere.
[...] 4, 2010 by C.R. According to a recent Marist Poll the other 26% of you are morons: There’s good news for American education. About three-quarters [...]
is it stupidity? … un-educated? …or Attention Deficit Disorder – AKA: a great excuse to never have to listen yet elicit sympathy.
PS – the person who spoke about meanings of words changing is right …’absolutely’ is the new ‘yes’ …just an observation.
It is simple, yes people are that stupid. Yes people will defend the stupidity with nonsense. No matter who you vote for there will be someone to shoot you down for it.
@JDW are you walking down the streets of Detroit or what? Not everyone who lives in the inner city would respond like that but I hope next time you are in a city you don’t make it back out.
Also Obama is just the same old presidents with a new paint job. Haters gonna hate that’s all, get over it people and do something productive.
@ most of the comments here- It seems very unlikely that there is any political demographic that performed better/worse than any other on this poll. If you are convinced that liberals or Obama voters are less intelligent than you, then I’d point out that you are engaging in the same snobbish type of “elitism” that you conservatives so often complain about from liberals. Personally I find your hypocrisy quite funny!
We citizens must demand that history be taught in our schools.
There is a benefit to required curricula.
Most frightening thing about the 26% who do not know that we fought to achieve independence from Great Britain is that they vote.
[...] who we’re celebrating our independence from this weekend, by the way (although 26% of us apparently do not know this) – and I think what the founding fathers had in mind is that they didn’t want any one [...]
Most amusing. I’m not a historian. I’m a mathematician. Yes, these polls all have inaccuracies, but if someone is educated enough and smart enough to realize that the name of the entity we declared independence from could be argued, then they are also smart enough to realize that the answer on the multiple-choice poll that’s closest to correct is Great Britain. The results of the poll can only be explained by the ignorance of some of those taking it. Also, look at the poll by region – correct answers were highest in the northeast and lowest in the south. One comment argued that the 26% ignorant were democrats, but the republican states of the south had 32% wrong answers. Incidentally, I’d be glad to take Carol’s be that Obama voters don’t know the answer (you can’t be a “liberal elitist” without some education – we sure aren’t elite based on income) and I’ve heard tea partiers declare that the census was against the constitution.
All these attacks on liberals in this forum are ridiculous. There are ignorant conservatives and liberals, and there are exceptionally intelligent conservatives and liberals. And all this talk about the younger generation being more unintelligent is ridiculous too. Stereotyping is the easiest way to get you into trouble. It’s like saying all Americans are fat and all the French are rude. They’re not. I happen to be a 19 year old liberal from a pretty well off family that probably has a higher IQ than a lot of the people who are commenting on this forum and I know who the colonies declared independence from and when the declared it. Don’t generalize and attack others with your own convoluted ideas of right and wrong. I just makes you look like an ignorant bigot, whether or not you know the answer to the poll question.
Americanos are stupido gringos.
If this poll is actually correct and they didn’t accidentally contact foreign citizens by mistake then all I can say is that now I understand why the United States is not even ranked in the top 50% in international polls of student education. I’m now actually embarassed to say I’m an American. This is depressing!
The United States and our Education is lost. The effort started years ago to hide our history and make up crap as they go. The State of Texas is demanding our real history and not this crap they call history now. The Library of Congress holds the histroy of this nation but socialist and communist want nothing more than to make this country “The Dumb Country”. By dumbing America down the government can control people better. An intelligent Patriot knows the value of freedom and those are a dying breed unless this country wakes up.
Well possibly several of these people were illegals and maybe more have just immigrated and possibly a few are people who have never had any education and have know idea what just happened.
Well, 74% decided to answer, 20% hung up the phone out of annoyance and 6% gave a silly answer to amuse themselves. Scientific explanation to this ridiculous survey.
The article reads, “6%… thought the U.S. separated from another nation.”
What am I missing? How were those 6% incorrect? Is England not another nation?
Maybe the residents polled were not even Americans. We have foreign residents. including diplomats, not to mention the countless illegals. To be meaningful, the poll should have been conducted with Americans. Or perhaps has the pollster forgotten the difference between citizen and resident.
[...] On July 4th 1776, We the People declared our Independence from Britain (should there be any question of that in my contemporaries minds). [...]
Can someone from Marist tell us if this was a multiple choice question? If so, what were the choices? If not, what answers were treated as equivalent to Great Britain?
I honestly have to say that this would have looked like a trick question to me, had I been one of the people polled. Of course I know that the United States declared independence in 1776 from an island kingdom with its capital in London. But what was the name of that kingdom in then? I know now that from 1707 through 1800 it was the Kingdom of Great Britain, but I didn’t know that last week. There must be many Americans who would answer England or United Kingdom. I would be surprised if 74 percent got this right without multiple choices. Please, Marist, tell us more about the poll.
Our educational system has been very poor these past three decades, so it is not surprising that they don’t know their history. Besides, one young girl I worked with in the 90′s told me point blank when I asked her about something on history, her answer I’ll never forget was, “Oh, that happened was before I was born.” Meaning, it didn’t count in her view. I told her it was before I was born as well. You see to her and others I guess, history only starts at the time of your particular birth. How unfortunate for these students not to know history, they are doomed to repeat the errors of the past because they never learned.
To Diego: Even if it was Europeans that answered the survey/poll, Europeans are far more educated and would know the answer to that question very easily.
[...] residents of this country do not know why we have a celebration on the Fourth of July. In fact, Marist Poll reports that 20% of residents had no clue who America declared independence from, and 6% named a [...]
[...] For more on the Marist Poll, click here. [...]
Grand has a good point.
Don’t take ANY poll for face value…. especially coming from a Keith Olberman who would say anything about anyone to get a taste of higher ratings.
[...] because we’re lazy and uninformed. Twenty-six percent of the persons responding to a recent poll did not know that the United States achieved its independence from Great Britain. Six percent [...]
[...] Apparently, 26% of American residents do not know that US declared its independence from Great Britain [...]
Norther Ireland officially belongs to the United Kingdom. Otherwise interesting to follow this discussion.. : -)
Paw1500t-7v noted that Northern Ireland officially belongs to the United Kingdom. True enough, now, but there was nothing called the United Kingdom until January 1, 1801. At the time of the American Revolution, there was just a Kingdom of Great Britain. The King of Great Britain was also the King of Ireland, but the kingdoms were legally separate. All of which contributes to the possibility that some people answered “don’t know” because they were confused about nomenclature, not because they didn’t know that the United States gained independence from some variant on England/Great Britain/UK. I wish someone from Marist would tell us if the poll was multiple choice, and if so, what the choices were.
[...] at around Independence Day. What do the other 26% think the U.S. declared independence from? France, China, Japan, Mexico, and Spain. Related [...]
[...] to have something funny to show. Well,… you may be right. But, maybe not. It seems that Marist recently conducted a poll that, if accurate, demonstrates this lack of basic knowledge by Americans about our heritage may [...]
PST, the formal legal beginning date of the United Kingdom was not 1801 but 1707, with the Acts of Union between England and Scotland, under Queen Anne.
A less formal date, because not legislated, could be set earlier, at the Union of the Crowns in March 1603, when James VI of Scotland became also James I of England, and thereafter styled himself “King of Great Britain…”.
Raven, this just goes to show how confusing the poll was, since there doesn’t seem to be agreement on what the kingdom was called between 1707 and 1801. It’s a trivial question of terminology, but it may have led to a misleading poll result if some people answered “Not sure” because of it. I respectfully disagree with you about when the United Kingdom began. There were Acts of Union in 1707 and 1800 (effective 1/1/1801), but the first of these — although it united two kingdoms — did not result in a kingdom with the word United in its name. It was just the Kingdom of Great Britain, and that is the country the U.S. attained independence from. It is interesting, though, that the Wikipedia article on the Kingdom of Great Britain describes the existence of a dispute over which name is proper for that span of years: plain old Kingdom of Great Britain or United Kindom of Great Britain.
Almost all of these comments are self-righteous and use assumptions, petty defense, or incorrect statements. I’d discuss all 113 of them individually, but I don’t have time.
Hey there,
I really don’t know so much about the history of the USA. Could you supply some images regarding on the US history, I am really lack of this information regarding on the history.
[...] the INS test immigrants must pass? (Warning, more than one-fourth of Americans surveyed last summer couldn’t tell you from what country we declared independence in [...]
[...] many surveys that find Americans just as lacking in U.S. history knowledge. One, conducted by the Marist Institute for Public Opinion, found 26% did not know from who the U.S. won its independence in 1776. Professors at the [...]
[...] that the sky is blue. Only a slight majority believes that global warming is real and just 74% think that the U.S. got its independence from Great [...]
[...] center located at Marist College, Poughkeepsie, New York). The polling data reflects that almost 30 percent of this country’s citizens are unaware of the history of our Republic. As pointed out in my article “Who is ignorant, Howard?” (see below), people being [...]
[...] this: 7/2: Don’t Know Much About History? July 2, 2010 by Marist [...]
I wanted to jot down a small note to appreciate you for all the splendid hints you are giving out here. My long internet look up has finally been paid with sensible ideas to go over with my family members. I ‘d state that that many of us website visitors actually are quite lucky to live in a wonderful place with very many lovely individuals with helpful concepts. I feel extremely lucky to have discovered your entire weblog and look forward to tons of more cool times reading here. Thank you again for all the details.
[...] * According to this Marist poll. [...]
[...] for Public Opinion gauged 1,004 US residents’ knowledge about history and civics education in a telephone survey reported in The Washington Post. One standout result was that seventy-four percent of those [...]
[...] significance of the British monarchy — let alone any monarchy,” Rudov said, citing a Marist poll that found 26 percent of Americans do not know that America won independence from England. “In my [...]
Hi there! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this article to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!
Good content, but honestly.. I think that everyones said the same thing that youve said over and over again. Dont you think its time for something newer, especially for a college site…?
[...] poll was taken by Marist Poll and published July 2, [...]
The fact that 26% of the respondents to the poll didn’t have an answer or a correct answering is disturbing but even more disturbing and troubling in regard to the health of our nation are the many bigoted, hateful, hostile comments that have been posted. The Republicans hate and denigrate the Democrats and vice versa — unfortunately for our country — we all live here and because of this ongoing unwillingness to attempt to work together to solve problems, we are pulling the country down and destroying it by insulting one another on stupid websites instead of actually DOING something constructive.
Good news for American education when 26% of those polled, did not know from what country the US obtained its independence? That’s more than a quarter of the people polled. That is a standard question, that requires a correct answer, on the citizenship examination given to all who apply for U.S. Citizenship, and the writer of this story thinks that the response from the poll is “good news for american education’? I must have fallen down Alices rabbit hole!
[...] A recent Marist Poll asked 1003 adults nationwide What year did the United Stated declared its independence? 58% of [...]
Well concidering I’m not American nor am I British.
I wouldn’t say I studied much in my days, but yet, I knew this, everyone at my office knew this, and heck, I bet even my granny knew this.
[...] else we know about our declining culture, standards, and our young people. As an example, a Marist Poll found that 1 of 4 Americans (26%) do not even know against which country the American Revolution [...]
Matt and Ed, without looking back at the prior discussion, what is the answer? I admit that I wasn’t sure. I knew that it was an island kindom in the North Atlantic off the coast of continental Europe with its capital in London and George III as its king. But that kingdom changed its name and its extent more than once in roughly the 18th century. What was it called in 1776? That’s the tricky part of the question. I don’t think most Americans know this with certainty, and I don’t think that it is particularly ignorant of them not to know.
[...] A recent Marist Poll asked 1003 adults nationwide What year did the United Stated declared its independence? 58% of [...]
With all the profoundly astute observations about the English language and some of the finer points of history, some people have lost sight of the fact the the question was framed within the context of July 4th.
Plenty of Saul Alinsky diversionary responses here but the reality of so many being so ignorant of their own country’s history is public education with decades of commie union teachers.
They have done their best to implement the communist manifesto by destroying as much knowledge of the founding of this country as possible.
Once they destroyed the knowledge base they proceeded to destroy the founders and then created millions of ignorant students who were then exposed to the numerous communist professors in our colleges and universities.
“the Books will be used since all can use Ibooks”
[...] percentage of people who didn't know that the US had declared independence against Great Britain in 1776. Then there is the fact that the Tea Party seems to look a LOT like the Republican Party distilled [...]