6/4: Put Sugary Drink Ban on Ice…Ban Goes Too Far, Says Majority

June 4, 2012 by  
Filed under Featured, NYC, NYC Poll Archive, Politics

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg caused a stir last week when he proposed the ban of sugary drinks larger than 16 ounces in establishments other than grocery and convenience stores.  What do New York City residents think about the proposal?  53% of adults in the Big Apple believe it’s a bad idea while 42% say it is a good one.  Six percent are unsure.

large sugary sodaClick Here for Complete June 4, 2012 NYC NY1-Marist Poll Release and Tables

“Unfortunately for Mayor Bloomberg, New Yorkers find the glass to be half empty on his proposal to ban super-size drinks,” says Dr. Lee M. Miringoff, Director of The Marist College Institute for Public Opinion.

By borough, the proposal is poorly received among residents in Queens and Staten Island and in Brooklyn.  58% of adults in Queens and Staten Island and 55% of those in Brooklyn say the ban is a bad idea.  However, 52% of Manhattan residents think the proposal is a good one.  In the Bronx, 49% say the plan is a bad idea while 44% think it’s a good one.

Even a majority of New Yorkers who want to lose weight — 51% — think the restriction is not a good idea.

And, while 42% of New York City adults report the idea is good health policy to fight the problem of obesity, 53% believe Bloomberg’s plan is an example of government going too far.  Five percent are unsure.

Many New Yorkers think there’s little point to the ban.  52% state the proposal won’t help people watch their weight.  45% disagree and say it will, and 3% are unsure.

The proposal made quite a splash.  67% have seen or heard about it including 39% who have heard a great deal about it and 28% who know a good amount.  16% haven’t heard or seen very much about the plan, and 17% know nothing at all about it.

When it comes to New Yorkers’ own drinking habits, the ban would affect less than one in five adults.  Just 17% of residents say they purchase a beverage larger than 16 ounces when they go out to eat, to the movies, or to a sporting event.  This includes 6% who report they do so very often and 11% who say they often do.  31% state it’s rare they make such a purchase, and 52% say they never buy super-size drinks.  Not surprisingly, 64% of those who purchase these large drinks think the mayor’s proposed ban is a bad idea.

Table: Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s Proposed Ban on Sugary Drinks in NYC

Table: NYC Sugary Drink Ban: Good Health Policy or Goes Too Far?

Table: Impact of Proposed Sugary Drink Ban on People’s Weight

Table: Aware of Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s Proposed Ban on Sugary Drinks in NYC

Table: Frequency of Buying a Drink Larger than 16 Ounces

Bloomberg Approval Rating at 45%

45% of registered voters in New York City believe Mayor Bloomberg is doing either an excellent or good job in office.  This includes 9% who say he is doing an excellent one and 36% who report he is doing a good one.  29% rate Bloomberg’s job performance as fair while 20% think he is performing poorly.  Six percent are unsure.

When NY1-Marist last asked this question in April, 44% gave the mayor high marks.  33% said he was doing an average job while 22% believed he fell short.  Only 1%, at the time, was unsure.

By borough:

  • Among voters in the Bronx, 36% approve of Bloomberg’s job performance.  This compares with 33% who thought this way in April.
  • In Brooklyn, 42% praise the mayor while a similar proportion — 46% — previously gave Bloomberg a thumbs-up.
  • 48% of registered voters in Queens and Staten Island believe the mayor is doing an excellent or good job in office while 44% had this opinion in April.
  • Looking at Manhattan, 50% approve of Mayor Bloomberg’s job performance.  This compares with 51% who shared this view in NY1-Marist’s April survey.

Table: Mayor Michael Bloomberg Approval Rating

Table: Mayor Michael Bloomberg Approval Rating Over Time

 

Trend graph: Bloomberg approval rating over time.

Click on the graph to enlarge the image.

How the Survey was Conducted

Nature of the Sample

 

Comments

7 Responses to “6/4: Put Sugary Drink Ban on Ice…Ban Goes Too Far, Says Majority”

  1. Michael from Manhattan on June 4th, 2012 11:45 pm

    How does it look if you break down support for the soda ban by information? Are people who are most aware of it most likely to support it?

  2. Gazette Watch: June 5, 2012 | Colorado Springs TEA Party on June 5th, 2012 12:32 pm

    [...] piece on p. A7, “Poll:  More against sugary drinks ban”, reports the results of a Marist/NY1 poll on Mayor Bloomberg’s proposal to ban the sale of sugary drinks in sizes over 16 ounces.  [...]

  3. Mary Azzoli on June 5th, 2012 3:28 pm

    @Michael: There is no statistical difference.
    - Mary Azzoli, Director of Interactive Media Systems, The Marist Institute for Public Opinion

  4. Bloomberg unbound: the New York mayor’s unaccountable third term | Harry J Enten | Give News Everyday on June 5th, 2012 6:02 pm

    [...] New York City residents are against the large soda ban by a 53% to 42% margin. In a rare rainbow coalition, Democrats, Republicans, Independents, whites, blacks, Latinos, young, old, rich, poor, college graduates, non-college graduates, men, women, soda drinkers, non-soda drinkers, people who want to lose weight, and people who don’t, all believe the ban to be a bad idea. Bloomberg has even gotten Jon Stewart to agree with Tucker Carlson.  [...]

  5. Bloomberg unbound: the New York mayor’s unaccountable third term | Harry J Enten | Firstpage Online UK News .co.uk on June 5th, 2012 11:15 pm

    [...] New York City residents are against the large soda ban by a 53% to 42% margin. In a rare rainbow coalition, Democrats, Republicans, Independents, whites, blacks, Latinos, young, old, rich, poor, college graduates, non-college graduates, men, women, soda drinkers, non-soda drinkers, people who want to lose weight, and people who don’t, all believe the ban to be a bad idea. Bloomberg has even gotten Jon Stewart to agree with Tucker Carlson.  [...]

  6. Healthy Lifestyle on October 15th, 2012 3:59 am

    I wouldn’t like this ban. Yes, sugary drinks are not good for us, but that seems like it’s going over the line. We should be free to drink whatever we want and if it has side effects, then we will deal with it, but they don’t have that bad enough side effects to ban. Do you agree or disagree?

  7. dak opbouw on November 26th, 2012 4:59 am

    Teveel suiker is niet goed voor het golestrol gehalte ! pas daar meer op

Feel free to leave a comment...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!